Exploitative

Here’s Why Shawn Mendes Is Being Called ‘Exploitative’ & ‘Unethical’ by Child Advocacy Groups

Exploitative
Superfame Logo

Exploitative or Smart: Child Advocacy Groups are not a fan of Shawn Mendes' contest. (Photo: Twitter)

Shawn Mendes, who is releasing his album Handwritten this week, is currently encouraging fans to buy out all the stock of his album from stores – for a small chance to meet him.

Despite the fact that album buyouts are a common debut-week stan activity, the CBC reports that various Child Advocacy Groups are calling Shawn and Universial Music’s latest marketing stunt “exploitative”, “unethical” and “irresponsible”.

Shawn Mendes Encourages Fans to Buy out Entire Stores of His Album Handwritten

“Go to your local retailer and BUY OUT all of their copies of the album and tweet a photo with #HandwrittenBuyouts and your location,” Shawn urges. “Buy ALL the album copies!”

The Golden Shawn Access Pass contest.

Buyers of the physical albums will have to sign up at Shawn’s official website with the code inside.

If luck is on your side, your profile on the website will show a “Winner’s Badge”, which might entitle you to a “Golden Shawn Access Pass”.

Shawn Mendes loves a buyout.

Winners of this mysterious pass will be able to win various prizes, including a “flyaway trip” to hang out with Shawn.

“Will you be the one to find the Golden Shawn Access Pass?” Shawn teases.

Shawn Mendes’ Stunt Criticized By Child Advocacy Groups as ‘Irresponsible’

Shawn and Universal Music’s  latest marketing campaign immediately caught the attention of multiple child advocacy groups. Most were concerned about the young age of his fans.

According to CBC, Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood’s Josh Golin branded the stunt “unethical”, while claiming that it was “really concerning”.

Fans buy Shawn Mendes' Handwritten.

Fans step out to support Shawn Mendes. (Photo: Twitter)

They said that kids are less likely to understand that the contest odds are stacked massively against them.

“To encourage kids to buy multiple copies…is exploitative.”

Media Smarts’ Matthew Johnson said, “Kids are going to be spending money that they don’t really have.”

“You’re taking advantage of people who don’t necessarily have the critical thinking skills…it’s irresponsible.”

Universal Music Canada did not respond to CBC.

Fans Don’t Care, Go Crazy for the Contest

Shawn Mendes fans did not care at all about the controversy – or their tiny chances of winning the contest.

Many proudly tweeted photos of themselves completely buying out “Handwritten” stock from stores.

Fan buys many copies of Handwritten.

Shawn Mendes is Set to Debut at #1 on the Billboard 200 With Over 100,000 Sales

According to Billboard and HitsDailyDouble, Shawn Mendes is projected to move around 100,000-120,000 copies of his album Handwritten.

This will be enough to project him into the #1 spot on the Billboard 200. His previous EP managed to garner a #5 spot with 48,000 copies sold.

Shawn’s main competition will be Reba McEntire’s Love Somebody and Tyler, the Creator’s Cherry Bomb – which are both projected to move around 55,000-65,000 copies each.

Is Shawn’s marketing ploy really endangering children, or just another over-reaction?

Want to write for us? Click here to apply!

Want updates? Want to comment? Like us on Facebook, follow our Tumblr or Twitter.


Trending Sponsors

Related Gossip You Might Like

Taylor Swift and Nash Grier.

Taylor Swift Calls Controversial Nash Grier ‘Sweet’ & ‘Talented’

SuperfameDecember 2, 2014
Luke Brooks from the Janoskians.

Janoskians’ Luke Brooks ‘Racist’ N-Word Tweets Cause Controversy

SuperfameApril 17, 2015
Taylor Caniff with Tyler Oakley and Lohanthony.

Taylor Caniff Blasts ‘Bullies’ Tyler Oakley & Lohanthony: “Karma Will Get You”

SuperfameJuly 16, 2015
Is Carter Reynolds bisexual?

Carter Reynolds Responds to Bisexual Rumors

SuperfameSeptember 7, 2015
Alex Ramos, Carter Reynolds and Deborah.

Alex Ramos Threatens to Punch Carter Reynolds as He Grinds up on Carter’s Ex-Girlfriend

SuperfameDecember 29, 2014
Amanda Steele.

Did Amanda Steele Disinvite Carter from Her Star-Studded Sweet 16 Party?

SuperfameJuly 28, 2015
Carter and Maggie.

Shots Fired: Carter Reynolds Calls Ex-Girlfriend Maggie ‘Lying, Cheating’

SuperfameJune 6, 2015
Cameron Dallas.

Cameron Dallas Apologizes to Fan after His Driver Runs over Her Foot

SuperfameAugust 14, 2015
Maggie Lindemann shades Cameron Dallas.

Maggie Lindemann Hits Back: Cameron Dallas Is Talentless & Not Famous!

SuperfameDecember 2, 2014
Bea Miller and Jacob Whitesides.

Jacob Whitesides Wants to Date Bea Miller, Wants You to Stop Being ‘Annoying’ About It

SuperfameApril 19, 2015
Cameron Dallas with Matt Espinosa.

Matt Espinosa Calls Cameron Dallas ‘Selfish’ for Trying to Revive Magcon

SuperfameJuly 19, 2015
Taylor Caniff.

Taylor Caniff Faces Felony & Common Nuisance Charges, following Police Raid

SuperfameSeptember 8, 2015
Ricky Dillon with Kian Lawley.

Watch the Snapchats of O2L’s Stripper & Fight-Filled, Drunken House Party Here

SuperfameJanuary 2, 2015
Alx James.

Alx James Claims ‘Spiteful’ Young YouTubers Spit on Fans at Playlist Live

SuperfameFebruary 10, 2015
Justin Bieber and Taylor Caniff.

Justin Bieber Fans Attack Taylor Caniff, Call Him Ugly

SuperfameJune 6, 2015